BOOKING A CIVIL MOTION DATE AT THE SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE – BRAMPTON

Now that many court appearances can be done virtually, lawyers have more flexibility in the files they can take on. In the past, a simple 15-minute scheduling appearance could mean hours of travel, so we had to be cautious about accepting matters in distant jurisdictions. Even though courts are gradually returning to in-person hearings, many procedural attendances are still conducted remotely, so lawyers are less likely to limit their practice to a single city.

One consequence of this is that we now need to understand how to navigate multiple administrative regions across Ontario. Each region has its own practice directions, booking systems, and unwritten customs, and those differences can easily cause delay or frustration if they are unfamiliar.

This blog is the first in a series where I will break down how to book a motion in various cities and towns across Ontario.

 

Short Motions (under 1 hour):

Although Brampton is part of the Central West Region, the practice directions create a few Brampton‑specific rules, starting with how short motions are booked.

Unlike Milton, Orangeville, Guelph, Owen Sound, and Walkerton, you cannot book a short motion in Brampton by emailing the court to request available dates. Instead, counsel must schedule short motions using the court’s online Calendly system.

Things to keep in mind for Short Motions:

– The practice directions include a helpful tip sheet on using Calendly, linked here

– Self-represented parties that do not have the technology or ability to access the internet may schedule the Short Motion by telephone

– Any cancellations or adjournments using Calendly must be on consent of the parties

– Cancellations and adjournments will not be accepted on Calendly within 10 days of the scheduled hearing date

 

Long Motions (over 1 hour):

To book a long motion, the parties must first adhere to a timetable for completion of all the necessary steps (i.e. delivery of materials, cross-examinations, etc.) to be considered “ready” to proceed with the motion hearing.

If the parties agree on a timetable, it can be sent to the court with a request that it be endorsed and made into a Court Order.

If the parties cannot agree on a timetable within 45 days of service of the moving party’s motion record, any party can request an attendance at Triage Court to set a timetable. This is done by completing the Requisition to Attend Long Motion Triage Court Form, linked here, and emailing it to SCJtrialofficebrampton@ontario.ca. In Brampton, triage court is held every Tuesday at 9:00 a.m.

Once the timetable has been set and complied with, the parties are considered “ready” to book their long motion hearing date. This is also done at triage court, using the same requisition and email process that applies if the parties cannot agree on a timetable and must attend triage court to set one.

Things to keep in mind for Triage Court:

– Gowns are not required at triage court

– Each matter at triage court is limited to 10 minutes

– It is the responsibility of the party scheduling the triage court date to inform the other parties immediately in writing

– Do not ask the judge for a motion date unless all of the steps in the timetable are adhered to – it will not go well

 

Staying current with the latest regional notices and practice directions helps avoid unnecessary delays and ensures that matters proceed smoothly. Stay tuned for my next blog post, where I walk through the process for another city or town in a different administrative region.

Please remember that scheduling procedures change frequently. Always review the most recent Central West Region practice direction and any local notices specific to Brampton before scheduling.

 

Colleen Dowling 

Nothing contained in this post constitutes legal advice or establishes a solicitor-client relationship. If you have any questions regarding your legal rights or legal obligations, you should consult a lawyer.

WHAT LAW SCHOOL DOESN’T TEACH YOU ABOUT GOING TO COURT

In law school, we learn how to read a set of facts, find the legal issues, the applicable legal tests, and apply them to answer some hypothetical question.

What we do not learn, at least not in detail, is how to prepare for court in practical ways, aside from knowing the law. This is where the articling experience comes in.

So far, in my articling term at Casey & Moss LLP, I have been fortunate to attend, observe, and even speak in court. I was understandably nervous at first, but I came to appreciate that pre-court nerves are part of the process, and everyone experiences them in some way or another (or so I’ve been told…).

Setting aside the inevitable nerves, my in-court experiences have taught me practical lessons that extend beyond what is covered in law school lectures. I share a few of them below.

Lesson 1: You Need to Read the Practice Directions. Then Read Them Again.

Before you step into a courtroom, you need to have read and understood the practice directions for that specific court. In fact, before even getting to the court part, you need to ensure that your filed materials comply with the court’s filing requirements.

Thankfully for me, at Casey & Moss LLP, our lawyers are diligent about updating one another on interesting finds in the practice directions and drawing attention to any important changes or new discoveries in the filing requirements.

As an articling student, I’ve witnessed how staying on top of these changes translates into preparation for court: A lawyer who knows the law can make an argument, but a lawyer who knows the law and the practice directions can make sure to have that argument heard.

Lesson 2: If You Raise It, You Better Know Where It Is in Your Evidence

Observing courtroom advocacy taught me that every oral submission must be grounded in the evidence, and that counsel must know precisely where that evidence can be found.

This means knowing:

  • The specific document in the evidentiary record that supports each part of your submission;
  • The Case Center reference for where it can be located;
  • The exact paragraph or page number you intend to direct the judge to; and
  • What you are asking the court to take away from that particular passage.

That level of familiarity does not happen by accident. Hours of prep go into it.

But there is also something reassuring about watching experienced counsel field questions from judges in real time. When asked a difficult question, they do not panic. Often, they respectfully pause their submissions to acknowledge the question, clarify what is being asked if needed, and either provide the pinpoint to the answer or ask for a brief opportunity to retrieve it during a break.

As the articling student, this often means you were diligently taking notes of the judge’s questions and flipping through the record, locating the exact document or paragraph, and flagging it for supervising counsel before submissions resume.

To do this effectively, I have found it essential to:

  • Read the pleadings and all materials before the court in advance. Reviewing them close enough to the hearing date to remain familiar with the details makes a significant difference in how well you can follow submissions and understand the issues as they unfold.
  • Become comfortable not only with the evidence itself, but also with the platform that houses it. In matters before the Superior Court of Justice, that platform is Case Center, the court’s mandatory document-sharing system. Being able to navigate it quickly and confidently is a practical and meaningful way to support counsel during a hearing.

Lesson 3: What To Wear to Court

Courtroom wardrobe logistics are not discussed in law school.

Some attendances require robes. Others, such as case conferences, do not (but read the practice directions to be sure!).

For now, as an articling student, my uniform is usually a black blazer. No one expects me to appear in robes I do not yet have, so at this stage, I am thankfully spared the added stress of wondering whether my robes are at home or at the office, though I understand that day will come soon enough.

But even when robes are not required, the setting remains formal, so suit jackets and blazers are always a good option when in doubt.

Lesson 4: You Can’t Drink Coffee in Court!

One of the most devastating news I found out through experience rather than education was that you cannot drink coffee in court. Nor can you eat anything, or chew gum. But hey, at least you can drink water!

Preparation includes these practical considerations. Eat beforehand. Bring a snack for the break. If you plan to grab lunch nearby, make sure you leave enough time not only for the food to arrive and to eat, but also to debrief with counsel or take care of any last minute tasks during the recess. As a student, and even as counsel, breaks may often be spent researching, finding documents, or tracking down pinpoints, so having food handy is always a good idea.

There are also smaller details that matter, many of which I learned through guidance from helpful court staff:

  • Your jacket should not be draped over the back of your chair, or lounging on top of a seat. Keep it on your lap or neatly tucked away behind your chair.
  • If you are taking notes, make it clear that you are doing so for legitimate reasons. Recording a court proceeding is not permitted in any shape or format. If you are typing on a phone or tablet, it can easily be misunderstood. It is better to clarify at the outset to court staff, before the hearing commences, that you are taking notes to assist counsel and are authorized to do so, and for no other purpose.

 

Those are all my list of lessons learned for now!

If you have others that I missed, feel free to send me an email: fseddigh@caseyandmoss.com. I’ll take all the courtroom tips I can get.

 

Fara Seddigh
Nothing contained in this post constitutes legal advice or establishes a solicitor-client relationship. If you have any questions regarding your legal rights or legal obligations, you should consult a lawyer.

REGIONAL PRACTICE DIRECTIONS – SCHEDULING, FILING, AND COMMUNICATING WITH THE COURTS

When it comes to scheduling a date with the courts and subsequently serving and filing materials, you must first consult your region’s Practice Directions. These handy guides provide detailed steps to ensure your date is secured and your materials are provided to opposing counsel and your presiding Judge.

 

The Superior Court of Justice is divided into eight different regions, each with their own Practice Direction:

  1. Central East: Barrie/Bracebridge, Newmarket, Oshawa, and Peterborough/Cobourg/Lindsay,
  2. Central South: Hamilton, Kitchener, St. Catherines, Welland, Brantford, Simcoe, and Cayuga
  3. Central West: Brampton, Orangeville, Guelph, Milton, and Owen Sound/Walkerton,
  4. East: Ottawa, Kingston, Belleville, Brockville, Cornwall, L’Orignal, Napanee, Pembroke, Perth, and Picton
  5. Northeast: Sudbury, Cochrane/Timmins, Gore Bay, Haileybury, North Bay, Parry Sound, and Sault Ste. Marie
  6. Northwest: Thunder Bay, Kenora, and Fort Frances
  7. Southwest: Chatham/Kent, Goderich/Huron, London/Middlesex, Sarnia/Lambton, St. Thomas/Elgin, Stratford/ Perth, Windsor/Essex, and Woodstock/Oxford
  8. Toronto: This region of the Superior Court of Justice includes the Estates List, Civil List, and Family List. Importantly, each of these lists have their own practice direction.

 

Practice Directions provide an up-to-date overview of the court’s scheduling, filing and administrative procedures. Importantly, these directions are separated by the subject of the matter, such as civil law, family law, and criminal law.

 

While each court will have varying directions, there are some consistencies across the regions, such as:

 

If you find that a region’s Practice Direction does not adequately address your questions, you can do the following:

  1. Consult the consolidated Provincial Practice Directions
  2. Contact the court’s administration and ask them to clarify their scheduling and filing procedures
  3. Review the Rules of Civil Procedure

*(When in doubt, it is always best practice to review the Rules. They govern the entire Superior Court of Justice and are the basis of all region’s court procedures.)

 

Remember to always read the most recent iteration of a region’s Practice Directions and Notices to the Profession. These guides are often amended to reflect updates to court’s scheduling and filing procedures.

 

Hannah Henley

Nothing contained in this post constitutes legal advice or establishes a solicitor-client relationship. If you have any questions regarding your legal rights or legal obligations, you should consult a lawyer.